Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Silver Moon" data-source="post: 894480" data-attributes="member: 8530">Great answer Steve, you've summed it up quite well.   I don't agree with you about Smallville, but I think you've hit everything else straight on.After the first X-Men film I heard many complaints from comic book fans, stating many of the same nit-picks pointed out in this thread, but most people had to admit that they hit just about every character head on, and at some point during the history of the comic that was EXACTLY how each character was portryed.   In two cases I felt the film actually improved upon any version of the comics, namely with the portrayal of the Toad and with Xaviar's school as a school for young mutants. Thought X-2 also kicked butt and was very true to the comics.  Haven't seen Daredevil but I heard it was as close as Spidy to capturing the feel of the comic books.   The Justice League cartoon is also pretty accurate.</blockquote>