Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 6002241" data-attributes="member: 22779">Just a point about production values.&nbsp; I gotta say, I do not see the 4e books as having lower production values than any other D&amp;D books.&nbsp; The editing has been, for an RPG product, absolutely stellar.&nbsp; Yeah, sure, you got the errata pdf's.&nbsp; True.&nbsp; But, if you actually compare, there is surprisingly little in the way of actual editing errors in the 4e books.&nbsp; Some, sure, but, very, very few.Heck, compare a first printing 3e PHB to a second printing 3e PHB if you want to see some extremely bad editing.&nbsp; Or go back to 2e books.&nbsp; Yikes.Most of the errata for 4e has either been in the form of clarifications, rather than outright mistakes.&nbsp; And the books have been pretty darn pretty as well.&nbsp; Other than the ink thing, which was a criticism that seemed to go away pretty quick, and the wavy pages thing (which WOTC had no control over), the actual physical books are pretty darn high quality.You can knock WOTC for a lot of things, but, production values isn't one of them.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hussar, post: 6002241, member: 22779"] Just a point about production values. I gotta say, I do not see the 4e books as having lower production values than any other D&D books. The editing has been, for an RPG product, absolutely stellar. Yeah, sure, you got the errata pdf's. True. But, if you actually compare, there is surprisingly little in the way of actual editing errors in the 4e books. Some, sure, but, very, very few. Heck, compare a first printing 3e PHB to a second printing 3e PHB if you want to see some extremely bad editing. Or go back to 2e books. Yikes. Most of the errata for 4e has either been in the form of clarifications, rather than outright mistakes. And the books have been pretty darn pretty as well. Other than the ink thing, which was a criticism that seemed to go away pretty quick, and the wavy pages thing (which WOTC had no control over), the actual physical books are pretty darn high quality. You can knock WOTC for a lot of things, but, production values isn't one of them. [/QUOTE]

Verification