Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="GMforPowergamers" data-source="post: 6422977" data-attributes="member: 67338">exactly, I can't in all fairness ask if my Ninja clan is in the place the DM just said it can't be, or ask if I could of grown up on the lost continant that just reappeared aafter 2,000 years (well I can ask but I can't get mad when the clear no that makes sense is given)the problem is the example was &quot;Get item from City, but PC can't do it, so a PC Ninja says &quot;Hey can my Ninkja clan be in these mountains and help&quot; no where is it in anyway canceling the challenge no where is it not&nbsp; making logical sense. no where is it breaking the world...OK, so help me. How do I explain that I believe that traditional role playing and D&amp;D as created by Dave and Gary and published by TSR then later WotC is a game with Variable amounts of PC Authorship and that it is not wrong deviant or anti tradition to ratchet that variable up or down?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="GMforPowergamers, post: 6422977, member: 67338"] exactly, I can't in all fairness ask if my Ninja clan is in the place the DM just said it can't be, or ask if I could of grown up on the lost continant that just reappeared aafter 2,000 years (well I can ask but I can't get mad when the clear no that makes sense is given) the problem is the example was "Get item from City, but PC can't do it, so a PC Ninja says "Hey can my Ninkja clan be in these mountains and help" no where is it in anyway canceling the challenge no where is it not making logical sense. no where is it breaking the world... OK, so help me. How do I explain that I believe that traditional role playing and D&D as created by Dave and Gary and published by TSR then later WotC is a game with Variable amounts of PC Authorship and that it is not wrong deviant or anti tradition to ratchet that variable up or down? [/QUOTE]

Verification