Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Infiniti2000" data-source="post: 2480960" data-attributes="member: 31734">So, to be consistent, you disallow a cleave off most charge attacks?&nbsp; Assuming you charge to one opponent, and the square you charge to is an invalid square against another opponent within range (invalid based on charging rules), then you can't cleave, right, because you couldn't attack that opponent in the first place from that position.&nbsp; I'm not sure I can come up with any other examples to show why your logic is faulty, but this one does at least.&nbsp;Common?&nbsp; Are you serious?&nbsp; All those commoners are going run past the BBEG wielding a spiky chain knowing they will die?&nbsp; Please!&nbsp; Be realistic.&nbsp; It's an impossible situation because of all the idiotic assumptions you have to make.&nbsp; Yes, it could legally happen much like 400 orcs could agree to form a straight line and pack in as tightly as possible for your lightning bolt, but it won't happen and no sane person would suggest that it would happen.&nbsp;So, by unfair do you mean unbalanced?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Infiniti2000, post: 2480960, member: 31734"] So, to be consistent, you disallow a cleave off most charge attacks? Assuming you charge to one opponent, and the square you charge to is an invalid square against another opponent within range (invalid based on charging rules), then you can't cleave, right, because you couldn't attack that opponent in the first place from that position. I'm not sure I can come up with any other examples to show why your logic is faulty, but this one does at least. Common? Are you serious? All those commoners are going run past the BBEG wielding a spiky chain knowing they will die? Please! Be realistic. It's an impossible situation because of all the idiotic assumptions you have to make. Yes, it could legally happen much like 400 orcs could agree to form a straight line and pack in as tightly as possible for your lightning bolt, but it won't happen and no sane person would suggest that it would happen. So, by unfair do you mean unbalanced? [/QUOTE]

Verification