Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Legildur" data-source="post: 3317807" data-attributes="member: 1258">Patryn has already done so.This argument has been hashed out many times already and the positions basically fall into three camps1. those that rely purely on the PHB and say Sunder is it's own Standard Action;2. those that rely purely on the PHB and say Sunder replaces a melee attack; and3. those that rely on the FAQ/RotG and say Sunder replaces a melee attack.And it has been shown repeatedly that the FAQ, while an admittedly useful document, is hardly error free or never contradicts the PHB.&nbsp; And the RotG articles have an even lower degree of accuracy and reliability.Personally, I hold to (1), though I can see why others might support (2) or (3).&nbsp; But this argument is old and has been covered in previous threads.&nbsp; Feel free to search for them and acquaint yourself with the arguments.&nbsp; All I am saying, mainly for the benefit of others, is that it is an area of debate and not simply an accepted universal ruling.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Legildur, post: 3317807, member: 1258"] Patryn has already done so. This argument has been hashed out many times already and the positions basically fall into three camps 1. those that rely purely on the PHB and say Sunder is it's own Standard Action; 2. those that rely purely on the PHB and say Sunder replaces a melee attack; and 3. those that rely on the FAQ/RotG and say Sunder replaces a melee attack. And it has been shown repeatedly that the FAQ, while an admittedly useful document, is hardly error free or never contradicts the PHB. And the RotG articles have an even lower degree of accuracy and reliability. Personally, I hold to (1), though I can see why others might support (2) or (3). But this argument is old and has been covered in previous threads. Feel free to search for them and acquaint yourself with the arguments. All I am saying, mainly for the benefit of others, is that it is an area of debate and not simply an accepted universal ruling. [/QUOTE]

Verification