Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="EzekielRaiden" data-source="post: 8674443" data-attributes="member: 6790260">It doesn't seem to me that suggestion would come across as doing harm to the PC warrior. If anything, I think the PC caster would feel relieved that there was &quot;no need to fight&quot;! &quot;Wow, &lt;Warrior PC&gt; can be super stubborn about things, I'm so glad you were able to smooth this over without it actually coming to blows. That would have been really bad!&quot;I would, however, allow the caster PC a chance to sell me on them getting an additional attempt to break the charm, or perhaps a bonus to future saves. Not because of &quot;indirect harm&quot; (which, again, I don't actually see here in the first place) but because of the gross illogic of the situation. Someone you and your friend were just about to fight, now you're friendly acquaintances and your warrior friend has left you alone with them? That's weird!</blockquote>

[QUOTE="EzekielRaiden, post: 8674443, member: 6790260"] It doesn't seem to me that [I]suggestion[/I] would come across as doing harm to the PC warrior. If anything, I think the PC caster would feel [I]relieved[/I] that there was "no need to fight"! "Wow, <Warrior PC> can be super stubborn about things, I'm so glad you were able to smooth this over without it actually coming to blows. That would have been really bad!" I would, however, allow the caster PC a chance to sell me on them getting an additional attempt to break the charm, or perhaps a bonus to future saves. Not because of "indirect harm" (which, again, I don't actually see here in the first place) but because of the gross [I]illogic[/I] of the situation. Someone you and your friend were just about to fight, now you're friendly acquaintances and your warrior friend has [I]left you alone with them?[/I] That's weird! [/QUOTE]

Verification