Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="harunmushod" data-source="post: 9542896" data-attributes="member: 7026983">I copied your post back into ChatGPT and asked it for the same analysis on Basic Roleplaying. Here is is what it said:Certainly! The Basic Roleplaying (BRP) system by Chaosium is an iconic generic RPG engine, but like other generic systems, its settings sometimes struggle to fully capitalize on the strengths of the rules. Here's an analysis of BRP's strengths, missed opportunities, and potential fixes---Basic Roleplaying (BRP): A System with History but Inconsistent Thematic IntegrationThe Problem:BRP is a robust and adaptable system with mechanics rooted in its percentile dice core, making it easy to grasp and versatile for different genres. However, the settings accompanying BRP often fail to emphasize its unique strengths. Many BRP settings, like Magic World or Superworld, are functional but feel generic, relying heavily on players or GMs to add depth. Even its more iconic settings, such as RuneQuest’s Glorantha, can feel overwhelming due to an overabundance of lore with insufficient guidance for new players.The Fix:1. Emphasize Genre-Specific Mechanics: BRP’s percentile system shines when it integrates tightly with a setting’s themes. Future BRP settings could expand upon genre-specific mechanics to highlight these themes. For example:A pulp adventure setting could add mechanics for dramatic stunts, resourceful improvisation, or escalating tension during cliffhangers.A space opera setting might benefit from expanded ship combat rules or faction-influence mechanics that leverage BRP’s skill system.2. Streamline Entry Points for Lore-Heavy Settings: Settings like Glorantha are rich in lore but can be daunting for newcomers. A "quick-start" region with limited factions, streamlined mechanics, and beginner-friendly narratives would make it easier for new groups to engage. Pre-designed adventures or “starter campaigns” could introduce key concepts without overwhelming players.3. Add Modular Story Hooks and Generators: BRP would benefit from tools that help GMs quickly create compelling scenarios. For instance:<ul> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">Random event tables tailored to different genres.</li> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">Faction and NPC generators that tie directly into a setting’s core themes.</li> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">"Conflict seeds" designed to kickstart player involvement in the world.</li> </ul>4. Introduce Dynamic Progression Systems: While BRP’s skill progression is straightforward, settings could incorporate mechanics that tie advancement to the narrative. For example:In a noir detective setting, uncovering truths might lead to both personal growth and darker consequences.A post-apocalyptic setting could use a resource scarcity mechanic where skill development is tied to survival achievements or alliances.5. Highlight Emotional and Ethical Consequences: Chaosium’s other games, like Call of Cthulhu, excel at creating emotional stakes and moral dilemmas. BRP settings could take inspiration from this by including:Faction reputation systems where player choices have tangible effects on alliances and world politics.Rules for personal bonds, rivalries, or internal conflicts that evolve throughout a campaign.6. Encourage Cross-Genre Play: BRP’s generic nature makes it ideal for campaigns that blend genres. A setting that combines fantasy with sci-fi or historical fiction with horror could include tailored mechanics for integrating disparate elements while maintaining a cohesive narrative framework.Example Applications:Fantasy (Magic World): Expand magic systems to reflect diverse cultural traditions within the setting. Introduce modular spell creation rules to give players greater narrative control over their magic use.Superheroes (Superworld): Flesh out the social implications of superpowers. Introduce systems for public perception, hero-vs-villain rivalries, and the emotional toll of power misuse.Historical Fiction: Add mechanics for managing historical accuracy vs. player agency, with rules for alternate history divergence.---Why It Matters:BRP is a system with a rich history and an intuitive core, but its settings often rely on players and GMs to inject life into the framework. By enhancing settings with narrative scaffolding, genre-specific mechanics, and emotional stakes, Chaosium could elevate BRP from a solid toolkit to a system that fully realizes the potential of its worlds.</blockquote>

Verification