Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Infiniti2000" data-source="post: 2821233" data-attributes="member: 31734">No, it's not reasonable because it's completely useless.&nbsp; There are no effects based on that definition.So, you actually roll a 5 and miss but you state that you roll a 6, and still miss.&nbsp; You cheated, but it's inconsequential.&nbsp; The cheating must have a noticeable consequence, otherwise a discussion on it is meaningless.&nbsp; And, as Mort (and probably others) points out, most people will consider cheating to be negative action and not a positive one.&nbsp; So, if you don't use it for gain or for some negative effect, it's not cheating.&nbsp; If you want to say that you cheat in someone else's favor for no benefit of your own, try to use a different word or start a different thread because those are definitely not the same concepts.&nbsp; Unfortunately, your definition explicitly removes all negative factors and changes the thread topic.I would say that an example of minor cheating would be to claim a critical threat instead of a mere hit.&nbsp; Or, perhaps to save vs. the flesh to stone instead of fail.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Infiniti2000, post: 2821233, member: 31734"] No, it's not reasonable because it's completely useless. There are no effects based on that definition. So, you actually roll a 5 and miss but you state that you roll a 6, and still miss. You cheated, but it's inconsequential. The cheating must have a noticeable consequence, otherwise a discussion on it is meaningless. And, as Mort (and probably others) points out, most people will consider cheating to be negative action and not a positive one. So, if you don't use it for gain or for some negative effect, it's not cheating. If you want to say that you cheat in someone else's favor for no benefit of your own, try to use a different word or start a different thread because those are definitely not the same concepts. Unfortunately, your definition explicitly removes all negative factors and changes the thread topic. I would say that an example of minor cheating would be to claim a critical threat instead of a mere hit. Or, perhaps to save vs. the flesh to stone instead of fail. [/QUOTE]

Verification