Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="BryonD" data-source="post: 5513060" data-attributes="member: 957">Just to throw in here, this is the typical kind of comment I recall clearly endorsing continuing to use the OGL post-GSL.&nbsp; Which I believe supports that he is being consistent on that.He was a VERY avid banner-waver for &quot;the current edition of D&amp;D&quot;, &quot;WotC&quot;, &quot;Scott and Linae&quot;, and, yes, &quot;the GSL&quot;.But, I'm not at all certain you can stretch that to include &quot;4E&quot; specifically meaning the specifics of that rule set.&nbsp; Again, clearly early on he WAS supporting 4E itself, and strongly so.&nbsp; But I think that fell clearly under the whole &quot;current edition&quot; umbrella.&nbsp; Even when he was still strongly supporting the GSL, he was talking about doing an alternate version of 4E that fixed it.&nbsp; So it doesn't follow that he loved the rule set itself.To be clear, he is just one guy and his opinion is no more meanignful than mine, yours, or anyone else's.&nbsp; I do not see this as any kind of appeal to authority on &quot;better gaming&quot;.&nbsp; But, it is the topic de moment, and I don't think your spin on it is quite right.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="BryonD, post: 5513060, member: 957"] Just to throw in here, this is the typical kind of comment I recall clearly endorsing continuing to use the OGL post-GSL. Which I believe supports that he is being consistent on that. He was a VERY avid banner-waver for "the current edition of D&D", "WotC", "Scott and Linae", and, yes, "the GSL". But, I'm not at all certain you can stretch that to include "4E" specifically meaning the specifics of that rule set. Again, clearly early on he WAS supporting 4E itself, and strongly so. But I think that fell clearly under the whole "current edition" umbrella. Even when he was still strongly supporting the GSL, he was talking about doing an alternate version of 4E that fixed it. So it doesn't follow that he loved the rule set itself. To be clear, he is just one guy and his opinion is no more meanignful than mine, yours, or anyone else's. I do not see this as any kind of appeal to authority on "better gaming". But, it is the topic de moment, and I don't think your spin on it is quite right. [/QUOTE]

Verification