Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Sacrosanct" data-source="post: 6362831" data-attributes="member: 15700">We're not talking about fighters.&nbsp; We're talking about ways that a caster might not be able to always cast the perfect spell, as is a requirement in the white room scenario.I'll also note that there were many reasons and examples given of these mitigation, and only one is needed to show how white room analysis is incredibly flawed.&nbsp; So even if only concentration spells could be interrupted, and even if you ignored all the other reasons, that is still enough to invalidate the white room.&nbsp; However, since there are several factors that apply (as mentioned in the list above), it just reinforces why using white room is not only flawed, but flawed horribly.Between ways a spell can be interrupted, the chances that the caster never learned the spell to begin with, the chances that the caster never prepped the spell to begin with, the chances that the caster doesn't have any available slots anymore, the chances that the caster doesn't have the components to cast the spell, etc, etc, and it should be abundantly clear that using a white room scenario to make an analysis to say the caster is better and/or can replace all other classes is lazy and fundamentally flawed.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Sacrosanct, post: 6362831, member: 15700"] We're not talking about fighters. We're talking about ways that a caster might not be able to always cast the perfect spell, as is a requirement in the white room scenario. I'll also note that there were many reasons and examples given of these mitigation, and only one is needed to show how white room analysis is incredibly flawed. So even if only concentration spells could be interrupted, and even if you ignored all the other reasons, that is still enough to invalidate the white room. However, since there are several factors that apply (as mentioned in the list above), it just reinforces why using white room is not only flawed, but flawed horribly. Between ways a spell can be interrupted, the chances that the caster never learned the spell to begin with, the chances that the caster never prepped the spell to begin with, the chances that the caster doesn't have any available slots anymore, the chances that the caster doesn't have the components to cast the spell, etc, etc, and it should be abundantly clear that using a white room scenario to make an analysis to say the caster is better and/or can replace all other classes is lazy and fundamentally flawed. [/QUOTE]

Verification