Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="dave2008" data-source="post: 8062658" data-attributes="member: 83242">OK, it seems we are using generic differently.&nbsp; I am using it simple to mean a made-up culture not tied to a specific setting (real or fictional). I absolutely think that is possible.&nbsp; I can't even believe it is worth debating.&nbsp; Now would you like it, I'm guessing not.&nbsp; But that doesn't mean it is not a &quot;generic culture.&quot;&quot;Backgrounds&quot; already pretty much serve the purpose of generic cultures I am talking about.&nbsp; They could be expanded a bit to include some of the &quot;cultural&quot; info that existing in the PHB race section, or a new cultural option could be created.&nbsp; Regardless, I don't think it needs to be tied to a specific setting.So, instead of continuing to argue the above points, which we simply appear destined to disagree on, why don't you answer the question, I have posed several times (at least some version of it):&nbsp; What should the Level Up! cultures be if they can't use an established setting (which they can't)?&nbsp; Should they make a new setting too, or should they attempt some default cultures and provide advice on how to cater or create ones for your own (or possibly established) settings? Or should the scrap the idea all together. If there even a 4th option?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="dave2008, post: 8062658, member: 83242"] OK, it seems we are using generic differently. I am using it simple to mean a made-up culture not tied to a specific setting (real or fictional). I absolutely think that is possible. I can't even believe it is worth debating. Now would you like it, I'm guessing not. But that doesn't mean it is not a "generic culture." "Backgrounds" already pretty much serve the purpose of generic cultures I am talking about. They could be expanded a bit to include some of the "cultural" info that existing in the PHB race section, or a new cultural option could be created. Regardless, I don't think it needs to be tied to a specific setting. [B]So, instead of continuing to argue the above points, which we simply appear destined to disagree on, why don't you answer the question, I have posed several times (at least some version of it): [/B] What should the Level Up! cultures be if they can't use an established setting (which they can't)? Should they make a new setting too, or should they attempt some default cultures and provide advice on how to cater or create ones for your own (or possibly established) settings? Or should the scrap the idea all together. If there even a 4th option? [/QUOTE]

Verification