Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Flamestrike" data-source="post: 6947994" data-attributes="member: 6788736">So? I wasnt discussing resting and healing. But I dont see the problem. You spend all your HD on a short rest (8 hours long in this case). If you roll above average then yes, after a nights rest you are back to full HP.Of course, HP are not 'meat' so all you've done is restored your pool of (using the PHB definition of HP) 'luck, resolve, the will to live and health'.Youre still as wounded (or not wounded depending on how the HP loss was narratted) as you were the day before. You feel a lot better though. Your resolve is strengthened, and you feel healthy and refreshed. You're down on your luck (whether you realise it or not) and any HP attrition you suffer from here on in will probably be an actual wound that will take at least a weeks bedrest to recover.Your statement is patently false. Ive been DMing a game for 12 levels and 2 years of real time roughly adhering to the 6-8/ 2 short rest guidelines (the occasional shorter or longer adventuring day, or solo encounter here or there) and have encountered no problems with the system.Logically it must be a user error on your side.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Flamestrike, post: 6947994, member: 6788736"] So? I wasnt discussing resting and healing. But I dont see the problem. You spend all your HD on a short rest (8 hours long in this case). If you roll above average then yes, after a nights rest you are back to full HP. Of course, HP are not 'meat' so all you've done is restored your pool of (using the PHB definition of HP) 'luck, resolve, the will to live and health'. Youre still as wounded (or not wounded depending on how the HP loss was narratted) as you were the day before. You feel a lot better though. Your resolve is strengthened, and you feel healthy and refreshed. You're down on your luck (whether you realise it or not) and any HP attrition you suffer from here on in will probably be an actual wound that will take at least a weeks bedrest to recover. Your statement is patently false. Ive been DMing a game for 12 levels and 2 years of real time roughly adhering to the 6-8/ 2 short rest guidelines (the occasional shorter or longer adventuring day, or solo encounter here or there) and have encountered no problems with the system. Logically it must be a user error on your side. [/QUOTE]

Verification