Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Celebrim" data-source="post: 6859980" data-attributes="member: 4937">Wisdom is a bundle of separate ideas, but so are all the different attributes.But as it pertains to clerics, what wisdom primarily represents is very clear, and its importance to clerics and all the related 'spiritual' classes is equally clear.Clerics in D&D are paragons of morality of some sort.  Evil clerics are paragons of evil.  Good clerics are paragons of good.  And so forth.  This is why the cleric cannot depart from their chosen morality.  By exemplifying an ideal, they become proxies for the deity that they serve, and as proxies are empowered to act as conduits for their deities divine power to act on the world.  So why then should their spell casting ability be based on Wisdom?  Because if intelligence represents knowing something, then wisdom represents being able to act on what you know and believe.  High intelligence gives a person the ability to clearly lay out the principles that they believe in a coherent manner.  High intelligence gives you the ability to elucidate complex moral philosophies.  But high wisdom gives you the ability to live like you claim or believe that you should.  High wisdom gives you the perceptiveness and discernment to recognize the actual crucial factors you should act on, even when you couldn't necessarily explain them clearly to yourself or others.  High wisdom gives you the willpower to act as you claim you should act, even when doing so is difficult or frightening.  High wisdom lets you act on faith in what you claim to believe, even when you aren't clearly able to see the end results.  Now sure, some deities might prefer their clerics to also be of high intelligence.  A deity with dominion over reason and knowledge will want their proxies to also exhibit the traits of intellect that they themselves prize.  And sure, some deities might prefer than their clerics also be of high charisma, if they themselves have dominion over things related to charisma and emotion, or if the deity believes in evangelism and encourages its proxies to engage in oration and so forth.  But all deities will expect their clerics to generally exhibit the traits of wisdom, because it is wisdom that makes a proxy trustworthy and faithful in their service.  Intelligence may allow you to write an essay on the attributes of a deity, but it is wisdom that gives you the discernment to apply that knowledge to this particular situation.There is also another very good reason why clerics (in general) shouldn't be based on charisma, and that is we already have an archetypal servant of a deity class that has a very different relationship to the deity and to the deity's worshipers.  And that class is the Paladin, which does prioritize charisma over wisdom.  The Paladin, rather than a being a proxy for the deity, acts as the living embodiment of the deity in the world.  People looking at a cleric see the deity's servant, but when they look at the Paladin they are looking at someone who is the deities physical representation.  And as such, the Paladin is empowered by both how attractive it makes the deity appear, and how attractive it is to the deity who sees in the Paladin someone like unto themselves (and who may even have the blood of the deity in their veins or is in some fashion specially anointed).  That isn't to say that Wisdom isn't also prized in the Paladin, but its a secondary stat the way that Charisma is a secondary stat of the Cleric.  Now, we could of course write into the rules in either 3e or 5e, exceptions to this general rule.  It might be the case that clerics if a CN deity with dominion over emotion, foolishness, insanity or spontaneity, don't prize wisdom at all because their deity likewise doesn't prize wisdom at all.  In that case, I would expect to see an option (or feat) which altered which ability spell-casting was based on - probably to Charisma.  Likewise, a deity of logic, reason, knowledge or magic, might care considerably more for how intelligent that the cleric was than how wise they were, since only those able to plunge into deep mysteries reflect the god's character anyway.  But those are departures from the norm we would expect for clerics.I will say - at the risk of nudging over the line on the board rules - that one of the biggest mistakes you can make as a GM with a varied polytheistic cosmology is assume that any or all of the deities have religions and beliefs that are fundamentally congruent with Judeo-Christianity, as if Judeo-Christianity was the only religion that existed or as if all religious belief in the real world was basically alike.  Nothing is weirder than having a bunch of polytheistic deities with varied ideologies, all acting like the monotheistic, jealous, fatherly, self-sufficient, faith demanding, evangelical Christian God, or having the lawfully inclined organized church of that deity with a hierarchy that mimics it, even when those deities are supposedly representing a radically different system of morality and belief.  'Faith' is not going to be considered a virtue by most polytheistic deities, either in the real world or most D&D cosmologies as presented.  D&D clerics are not performing miracles based on Faith; they are casting spells that have been entrusted to them to use as they will.  Most D&D deities are not going to care if you only worship them, and many will actively encourage the worship of spouses, sons, daughters, or lieges as part of their worship.  Most D&D deities are going to have limited dominions that make worship of them limited anyway, so that even actual clerics of a deity will not be exclusive worshipers of that deity but celebrants of other deities as well.  As much as 1/3rd of D&D deities will have no organized 'church' and no hierarchy at all, because they reflect a system of belief that finds organized religion and hierarchies repellant anyway.  Indeed, some chaotic deities might discourage worship and supplication to them, preferring their beliefs to be expressed through equality, self-actualization, and mutual respect.  Many D&D deities will have religions that are secretive and esoteric and will not actively evangelize or spread their teachings.  As such, they won't care in the slightest whether their clerics are great orators or magnetic personalities.  Most D&D deities will not love their worshipers or expect love as an emotional regard you have for them, and for that matter most worshippers will not love the deity either.  In fact, most D&D clerics would probably consider it weird to suggest that they love their deity, as their deity would certainly not consider this to be the most appropriate form of worship.  Many if not most deities will be perfectly happy to be propitiated and appeased, and really won't care why you perform rituals in their honor or what is in your heart when you are doing them so long as you perform them.  In short, arguments that D&D clerics should have the attributes or theology that the person perceives in a real world institution like the Catholic Church are fundamentally flawed and based on ignorance both of the great variety of real world religious expression, and often even on simplified stereotypes regarding the Catholic Church.And to be even more pointed about it, the ideal that piety has no relationship to reason I find both self-evidently wrong and personally insulting.  You can speak about your own piety however you like.  Maybe your piety has no basis in reason, or maybe you see piety without reason as ideal.  But the idea that someone like Thomas Aquinas didn't base his piety on reason ought to be self-evidently wrong.</blockquote>

Verification