Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="SableWyvern" data-source="post: 9440108" data-attributes="member: 1008">Wouldn't cause any problems at my table (maybe some gentle mocking of the player, that's about it). It really is quite shocking to me how much friction and frustration you keep telling us you expect at your table, and for really minor things.Edit to add: If it was a really critical moment, with a risk of a TPK or something like that, there's a good chance I'd clarify if the player understood what they were asking. Similarly, if the group was discussing a plan, and getting someone to jump out of a window was a key component, I'd probably speak up if none of the other players did.Otherwise, the spell still takes an opponent out for a round, and does exactly what it should under the circumstances. I really, really don't see why anyone would expect players to respond with frustration and anger and, as I've mentioned previously, I would simply not play with people who would treat this as some terrible travesty or decide it's a good reason to halt the game for an argument.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="SableWyvern, post: 9440108, member: 1008"] Wouldn't cause any problems at my table (maybe some gentle mocking of the player, that's about it). It really is quite shocking to me how much friction and frustration you keep telling us you expect at your table, and for really minor things. Edit to add: If it was a really critical moment, with a risk of a TPK or something like that, there's a good chance I'd clarify if the player understood what they were asking. Similarly, if the group was discussing a plan, and getting someone to jump out of a window was a key component, I'd probably speak up if none of the other players did. Otherwise, the spell still takes an opponent out for a round, and does exactly what it should under the circumstances. I really, really don't see why anyone would expect players to respond with frustration and anger and, as I've mentioned previously, I would simply not play with people who would treat this as some terrible travesty or decide it's a good reason to halt the game for an argument. [/QUOTE]

Verification