Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="pemerton" data-source="post: 9446328" data-attributes="member: 42582">I don't understand your reasoning about Goodberry: in the real world people can feel full but be undernourished (if they fill up on, say, celery) or can be nourished yet feel hungry (I don't think I need to elaborate on this possibility!). So to me it seems an open question what effect Goodberry has, as far as feeling full is concerned.As far as Command is concerned, as I've already posted D&amp;D is incredibly pedantic about action economy and effects. Taking an action can range from (say) opening a door to (say) calling down a meteor swarm. From stepping over a buddle to (say) leaping over a cliff into a river of lava. And the game ranks these actions and their effects in all sorts of ways.How does Command fit into that ranking? The only guidance the spell gives us is its examples. Thus I take these to set the parameters, and hence to preclude commands such as &quot;Cast!&quot; or &quot;Attack!&quot; or &quot;Hurl!&quot;</blockquote>

[QUOTE="pemerton, post: 9446328, member: 42582"] I don't understand your reasoning about Goodberry: in the real world people can feel full but be undernourished (if they fill up on, say, celery) or can be nourished yet feel hungry (I don't think I need to elaborate on this possibility!). So to me it seems an open question what effect Goodberry has, as far as feeling full is concerned. As far as Command is concerned, as I've already posted D&D is [I]incredibly[/I] pedantic about action economy and effects. Taking an action can range from (say) opening a door to (say) calling down a meteor swarm. From stepping over a buddle to (say) leaping over a cliff into a river of lava. And the game ranks these actions and their effects in all sorts of ways. How does Command fit into that ranking? The only guidance the spell gives us is its examples. Thus I take these to set the parameters, and hence to preclude commands such as "Cast!" or "Attack!" or "Hurl!" [/QUOTE]

Verification