Comparing Modern Gear to Historical


log in or register to remove this ad

I did not watch the video, but read through the article with pictures. Certainly worth looking through.

It does show that old-timers knew a thing or two. I do see feeds to the YouTube about old secrets the modern whatever does not want you to know. Some look more legit than the one secret for destroying belly fat or whatever.
 

Ditto on read but not watched.

I like the notion. I'm also rather envious (these guys are doing what I'd love to be doing rather than be a corporate hack). One TBI and a diagnosis of Raynaud's syndrome ago and I might have chosen that lifestyle.

Two lines stuck out to me: "'The Mallory shoe went through 40 pairs of hands doing little technical details,' Ross says. 'It was an enormous undertaking because boots like that nowadays simply aren’t made.'" and "The historic gear worked spectacularly well, but it came with a caveat: it required immense skill to operate." These highlight a point sometimes lost in 'then-now' comparisons -- a lot of the reasons for modern gear changes absolutely and intentionally are for reasons of convenience (or novice accessibility) and/or because hand-crafted gear would be prohibitively expensive today. No argument, no contest, 'better at the task' was not the reason for its' adoption. A huge amount of it has always been about getting your cousin Steve backpacking in the gear, not because Shackleton (or Will Steger) would have done better using it.

Great article. Does the video say if they are going to publish somewhere? I did efficacy and specificity research on the Stroop Cognitive Test back in my public health grad school days, and would love to see an article on its' use in a setting like this.
 

I read a really interesting "true adventure" book called "The Brendan Voyage" (Tim Severin) about his attempt to recreate the voyage of St. Brendan the Navigator by crossing the North Atlantic in a reproduction of a 6th-century Irish leather boat.

It's a fascinating story and one of the most interesting takeaways was how much better traditional materials and food storage handled the harsh environment. They went far more old-school during the second season of the voyage and had a much better time of it.

Highly recommended read for anyone who enjoys that sort of thing.
 

Recent & Upcoming Releases

Remove ads

Top