Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="FrogReaver" data-source="post: 7787592" data-attributes="member: 6795602">The argument is that when you have a shield equipped the +2 AC is almost always better than making a third attack.&nbsp; The question of balance arises when comparing sword and shield using the +2 AC bonus action to two handed weapon.Even then, there's always some efficiency in being able to choose which action to use at what time.&nbsp; Suppose there were 2 actions one did double damage to enemies that were an even number of feet tall.&nbsp; The other did double damage two enemies that were an odd number of feet tall.&nbsp; Then provided you face an equal number of evenly and oddly tall people - then you have increased your average damage by being given the choice of being able to choose an equally comparable action.&nbsp; Sure, but the question here isn't one about sword and shield making the attack or taking the AC.&nbsp; The AC action is a better use of your third action in nearly all situations than a third attack.&nbsp; Thus, the action granted by equipping a shield doesn't fall in the category of an action that provides an option but no general benefit.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="FrogReaver, post: 7787592, member: 6795602"] The argument is that when you have a shield equipped the +2 AC is almost always better than making a third attack. The question of balance arises when comparing sword and shield using the +2 AC bonus action to two handed weapon. Even then, there's always some efficiency in being able to choose which action to use at what time. Suppose there were 2 actions one did double damage to enemies that were an even number of feet tall. The other did double damage two enemies that were an odd number of feet tall. Then provided you face an equal number of evenly and oddly tall people - then you have increased your average damage by being given the choice of being able to choose an equally comparable action. Sure, but the question here isn't one about sword and shield making the attack or taking the AC. The AC action is a better use of your third action in nearly all situations than a third attack. Thus, the action granted by equipping a shield doesn't fall in the category of an action that provides an option but no general benefit. [/QUOTE]

Verification