Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Water Bob" data-source="post: 7708239" data-attributes="member: 92305">They are trying hard to put out a quality game.&nbsp; They are doing everything &quot;right&quot;, in my opinion, except that they made one really bad decision that is killing them.They decided to go with the 2d20 mechanic instead of something more traditional.Sure, there are tons of people who like the mechanic and the game.&nbsp; I bet the game is selling well.But, my gut tells me (given all the people out there, like me, who dislike the mechanic--and there are several, from what I've seen) that they're not maximizing their niche.&nbsp; You'll never make everyone happy, but I feel as if they are getting 75% of their potential market rather than 90% because of the choice they made going with 2d20.Had they gone with something--a new system, or an old established system--that was more traditional in nature, I'd be happy as clam at the bottom of the ocean and yelling at the top of my lungs, &quot;Modiphius is awesome!&quot;Instead, I am disappointed, along with a sizable portion (but not a majority) of their market.2d20 is a huge mistake.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Water Bob, post: 7708239, member: 92305"] They are trying hard to put out a quality game. They are doing everything "right", in my opinion, except that they made one really bad decision that is killing them. They decided to go with the 2d20 mechanic instead of something more traditional. Sure, there are tons of people who like the mechanic and the game. I bet the game is selling well. But, my gut tells me (given all the people out there, like me, who dislike the mechanic--and there are several, from what I've seen) that they're not maximizing their niche. You'll never make everyone happy, but I feel as if they are getting 75% of their potential market rather than 90% because of the choice they made going with 2d20. Had they gone with something--a new system, or an old established system--that was more traditional in nature, I'd be happy as clam at the bottom of the ocean and yelling at the top of my lungs, "Modiphius is awesome!" Instead, I am disappointed, along with a sizable portion (but not a majority) of their market. 2d20 is a huge mistake. [/QUOTE]

Verification