Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="EzekielRaiden" data-source="post: 6586349" data-attributes="member: 6790260">Wow. I just...wow. The staggering size of the excluded middle is leaving me dizzy and breathless.Not only must I agree that 4e failed (when, by comparison to any other RPG except the breakaway success that is Pathfinder, it was a RIOTOUS success), but I either have to say that 4e wasn't D&amp;D because it wouldn't have &quot;failed&quot; without that name, or I have to say that 4e was simply inherently flawed and could not possibly succeed under any circumstances.I can see that the conversation has gone pretty far afield now, but...again, just wow. Couldn't at least have put an &quot;other&quot; in case people disagreed with something about both of the positions you provided, since it's not possible to dispute that 4e was a failure, with the way you've written them? As it stands, the poll is of the same form as, &quot;Confirm or deny: you are still beating your spouse.&quot; Thus my own answer is the same as my answer to that question: mu. (And not simply because I don't have a spouse.)</blockquote>

[QUOTE="EzekielRaiden, post: 6586349, member: 6790260"] Wow. I just...wow. The staggering size of the excluded middle is leaving me dizzy and breathless. Not only must I agree that 4e failed (when, by comparison to any other RPG except the breakaway success that is Pathfinder, it was a RIOTOUS success), but I either have to say that 4e wasn't D&D because it wouldn't have "failed" without that name, or I have to say that 4e was simply inherently flawed and [I]could not possibly succeed under any circumstances.[/I] I can see that the conversation has gone pretty far afield now, but...again, just wow. Couldn't at [I]least[/I] have put an "other" in case people disagreed with something about both of the positions you provided, since [I]it's not possible to dispute that 4e was a failure[/I], with the way you've written them? As it stands, the poll is of the same form as, "Confirm or deny: you are still beating your spouse." Thus my own answer is the same as my answer to that question: mu. (And not simply because I don't have a spouse.) [/QUOTE]

Verification