Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Cleon" data-source="post: 9434254" data-attributes="member: 57383">Giving them both the Construct and Planar Monster Type is a  bit bizarre and I can't offhand think of any official BECMI monster that has such.It also has a logical clash with their description: Bielgorad die rather than submit to mind-control but in BECMI, like 3E, creatures of the Construct Type are immune to mental effects (charm, sleep, illusions, etc.) so mind-controlling them is impossible.I'd make them regular living Outsiders with a few construct-style traits like immunity to poison and the inability to reproduce (since they are creations of The Shepherd).The (Enchanted) type is for creatures that are vulnerable to protection from evil and the like, and is used for monsters that can only be harmed by magical weapons or are magically summoned or controlled.That tells me they're definitely Outsider (Extraplanar) in 3E terms and I'd be happy throwing in Goatkin too.They definitely aren't Native Outsiders like the Prime Material Goatkin.I did muse over whether they are Tanar'ri in 3E terminology, but that subtype isn't used in the SRD so I wouldn't recommend it.Shall we giving them (Chaotic, Evil) too, for good measure?<a href="https://www.enworld.org/posts/9409816" target="_blank">Bielgorad</a>Large Outsider (Chaotic, Extraplanar, Evil, Goatkin)</blockquote>