Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mistwell" data-source="post: 3420332" data-attributes="member: 2525">Sigh.You guys have fun debating this with yourself.&nbsp; One of you is saying we don't know (which is not a helpful answer really).&nbsp; The other is saying &quot;That's one reasonable way to do it, but I prefer this other reasonable way&quot;.Okay, fair enough.&nbsp; In one of your games you will throw up your hands and say you don't know.&nbsp; In the other, you will calculate it a slightly different way.But in most of our games, it looks like we are going to do it the way CustServ suggested...because we came to that same conclusion without that CustServ advice, and that conclusion is one logical and consistent interpretation of the rules.Unless someone has an argument for why a different method is actually superior, as opposed to simply different and also a reasonable method, I think my part of this debate is done.&nbsp; Thanks for the advice, and I do appreciate it.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mistwell, post: 3420332, member: 2525"] Sigh. You guys have fun debating this with yourself. One of you is saying we don't know (which is not a helpful answer really). The other is saying "That's one reasonable way to do it, but I prefer this other reasonable way". Okay, fair enough. In one of your games you will throw up your hands and say you don't know. In the other, you will calculate it a slightly different way. But in most of our games, it looks like we are going to do it the way CustServ suggested...because we came to that same conclusion without that CustServ advice, and that conclusion is one logical and consistent interpretation of the rules. Unless someone has an argument for why a different method is actually superior, as opposed to simply different and also a reasonable method, I think my part of this debate is done. Thanks for the advice, and I do appreciate it. [/QUOTE]

Verification