Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="pawsplay" data-source="post: 3426848" data-attributes="member: 15538">What strawman are you talking about? Here's the deal. The EXAMPLE, the thing that's supposed to make everything clearer, itself raises huge questions. What you're basically saying is that Smurf cannot use the example that has been put forward, because that example has more holes than swiss cheese. Every single time Smurf gives another example that takes the MIC guidelines, piledrives them, then runs off with their girlfriend, the point is either greeted with silence or we get &quot;well, that's just an example.&quot;But if it were an example, it would work, right? But it doesn't. This is like getting instructions for a book case that tells you to fit Tab A into Slot A, but the tabs are labeled A - E and the slots F - J. And the picture in the book shows you doing something that you've already determined is physically impossible. And what it's calling &quot;shelves&quot; are shaped like ovals. The stupid dwarven axe is the worst possible example, unless they wanted to explain a lot more than they did. And it's STILL not 100% relevant as a rules citation, since the properties being added to the axe are still properties that can be added to any weapon, which the &quot;echoblade property&quot; is not.Which makes the CustServ answer still worse than useless.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="pawsplay, post: 3426848, member: 15538"] What strawman are you talking about? Here's the deal. The EXAMPLE, the thing that's supposed to make everything clearer, itself raises huge questions. What you're basically saying is that Smurf cannot use the example that has been put forward, because that example has more holes than swiss cheese. Every single time Smurf gives another example that takes the MIC guidelines, piledrives them, then runs off with their girlfriend, the point is either greeted with silence or we get "well, that's just an example." But if it were an example, it would work, right? But it doesn't. This is like getting instructions for a book case that tells you to fit Tab A into Slot A, but the tabs are labeled A - E and the slots F - J. And the picture in the book shows you doing something that you've already determined is physically impossible. And what it's calling "shelves" are shaped like ovals. The stupid dwarven axe is the worst possible example, unless they wanted to explain a lot more than they did. And it's STILL not 100% relevant as a rules citation, since the properties being added to the axe are still properties that can be added to any weapon, which the "echoblade property" is not. Which makes the CustServ answer still worse than useless. [/QUOTE]

Verification