Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Drawmack" data-source="post: 865541" data-attributes="member: 4981">Since you didn't feel the need - let's take a look at the rule.1) If you lived in a world where people who protected the wilds had this type of power and you ordered a forest cleared would you sleep in a room without a guard sitting next to your bed?2) It does say a melee weapon, I would rule that this means non-natural attack, but that is house rule so I won't go there.3) The attacker automatically hits, and scores a critical hit. Okay so what's the ciritcal on a bat's bite? Oh look at that a bat has no attackes, guess a bat can't coupe de gras after all.You are using a very loose interpretation of the rule and it's interaction with other rules.A gnat? c'mon - look at the save, desides a gnat does no damage.First of all this should really be in house rules. Secondly, I have been dming 3e for 2 years now and I've only seen a cdg used twice and once was by me. In your old thread you were told multiple times, by multiple people that the way you used the rule was in error, and yet here you are again without giving the set up, hoping to rally the troops of the uninformed again.</blockquote>