Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="DrSpunj" data-source="post: 5980" data-attributes="member: 994">Yeah, I have to agree with dcollinsEspecially since he was one of a couple people who helped me through this same question on the old boards.&nbsp; I wish they were up so everyone could glance back over there (the thread is less than a week old and titled something like &quot;MI Creation and a Ring of Three Wishes&quot;).I was trying to do the math for that Ring and several other magic items and stumbling over the errata'd passage.&nbsp; As many have previously stated, the example is pretty straightforward about the process and cost as long as you use the &quot;Single use, use-activated&quot; line from Table 8-10 on pg. 242.As Spikey said above, if you interpret things to mean every spell must actually be *cast* every day, actually spending all material components and XP costs, then certain items (like the Ring of Three Wishes) would essentially never be made by mortals.&nbsp; While most people would probably agree 20th level casters are fairly rare, they certainly should be able to make a Ring that casts Wish three times without casting and paying the XP cost for the spell (23*3=) 69 times.Thanks.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="DrSpunj, post: 5980, member: 994"] [b]Yeah, I have to agree with dcollins[/b] Especially since he was one of a couple people who helped me through this same question on the old boards. I wish they were up so everyone could glance back over there (the thread is less than a week old and titled something like "MI Creation and a Ring of Three Wishes"). I was trying to do the math for that Ring and several other magic items and stumbling over the errata'd passage. As many have previously stated, the example is pretty straightforward about the process and cost as long as you use the "Single use, use-activated" line from Table 8-10 on pg. 242. As Spikey said above, if you interpret things to mean every spell must actually be *cast* every day, actually spending all material components and XP costs, then certain items (like the Ring of Three Wishes) would essentially never be made by mortals. While most people would probably agree 20th level casters are fairly rare, they certainly should be able to make a Ring that casts Wish three times without casting and paying the XP cost for the spell (23*3=) 69 times. Thanks. [/QUOTE]

Verification