Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="sfedi" data-source="post: 2746490" data-attributes="member: 15746">In my group we´ve been arguing about if a Wizard could create a scroll of Cure Light Wounds if a Cleric assisted him (a Cleric without the Scribe Scroll feat, that is).Is this possible?If it is, can you post how the rules support this?If this is not possible, why?FYI the arguments goes something like this:-The Scribe Scroll Feat explicitly says that you must know the spell you are scribing. Note that it doesn´t mention prerequisites, just this requirement. OTOH, all the other item creation feats, mention the prerequisites for creating items.-Yes, you must know the spell to be scribed, BUT, there´s a rule that says that whenever a spell is required in the prerequisites of an item, that spell can be provided by another spell caster that knows/casts the spell-Since scrolls don´t have a prerequisite (at least explicitly stated) that you must know the spell scribed... you can´t apply the previous rule</blockquote>

[QUOTE="sfedi, post: 2746490, member: 15746"] In my group we´ve been arguing about if a Wizard could create a scroll of Cure Light Wounds if a Cleric assisted him (a Cleric without the Scribe Scroll feat, that is). Is this possible? If it is, can you post how the rules support this? If this is not possible, why? FYI the arguments goes something like this: -The Scribe Scroll Feat explicitly says that you must know the spell you are scribing. Note that it doesn´t mention prerequisites, just this requirement. OTOH, all the other item creation feats, mention the prerequisites for creating items. -Yes, you must know the spell to be scribed, BUT, there´s a rule that says that whenever a spell is required in the prerequisites of an item, that spell can be provided by another spell caster that knows/casts the spell -Since scrolls don´t have a prerequisite (at least explicitly stated) that you must know the spell scribed... you can´t apply the previous rule [/QUOTE]

Verification