Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Son of the Serpent" data-source="post: 7877880" data-attributes="member: 7015476">Like i said.&nbsp; Fine.&nbsp; No edition wars.&nbsp; But the thread is literally titled &quot;Critiquing the system&quot; so remarking negatively on bad aspects of editions is going to happen to some degree in this thread, it has nothing to do with edition wars, and to some extent you're just gonna have to acknowledge that for this comversation we are having right now that is completely normal.&nbsp; I shall refrain from trash talking the edition, but that is it.&nbsp; The fact it is probably viewed by a large number of people to be the worst edition for a great many reasons and a step in a bad direction is going to come up somewhat.&nbsp; As 5e borrows some stuff from it its highly relevant and at least to some degree people will speak about what they think 5e did right or wrong mechanically and otherwise and it will frequently be the case that in comparing it to other editions for analysis sake, some other editions may end up being critiqued and spoken negatively or positively of as well.&nbsp; Perhaps i shouodnt have said i call it &quot;ee&quot; but critiquing 4e is very relevant to critiquing 5e for some potential aspects of conversation.&nbsp; Same goes for other editions.Thats all ill say on this topic.&nbsp; And yes.&nbsp; I agree.&nbsp; Lets not quibble.&nbsp; But negative critique does not constitute an edition war.&nbsp; So there will be some.&nbsp; Its normal.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Son of the Serpent, post: 7877880, member: 7015476"] Like i said. Fine. No edition wars. But the thread is literally titled [B][I]"Critiquing the system"[/I][/B] so remarking negatively on bad aspects of editions is going to happen to some degree in this thread, it has nothing to do with edition wars, and to some extent you're just gonna have to acknowledge that for this comversation we are having right now that is completely normal. I shall refrain from trash talking the edition, but that is it. The fact it is probably viewed by a large number of people to be the worst edition for a great many reasons and a step in a bad direction is going to come up somewhat. As 5e borrows some stuff from it its highly relevant and at least to some degree people will speak about what they think 5e did right or wrong mechanically and otherwise and it will frequently be the case that in comparing it to other editions for analysis sake, some other editions may end up being critiqued and spoken negatively or positively of as well. Perhaps i shouodnt have said i call it "ee" but critiquing 4e is very relevant to critiquing 5e for some potential aspects of conversation. Same goes for other editions. Thats all ill say on this topic. And yes. I agree. Lets not quibble. But negative critique does not constitute an edition war. So there will be some. Its normal. [/QUOTE]

Verification