Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Rocket your D&D 5E and Level Up: Advanced 5E games into space! Alpha Star Magazine Is Launching... Right Now!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Messageboard Golem" data-source="post: 2011421" data-attributes="member: 18387">Well-contructed guide to monster-makingReviewer: jaundicedeye from Hollywood, California, USA"Crossbreeding: Flesh and Blood" is part of the Mongoose Publishing "Encycloaedia Arcane" line of accessory books for d20 fantasy role playing games such as Dungeons & Dragons. It is a handbook for players and GMs who want a standardized set of easy-to-consult rules for crossbreeding animals and/or monsters to make new creatures.This is one of the "crunchiest" Encycloaediae Arcane I have seen. The inside front and back covers are filled with the crossbreeding tables from the book, and make using "Crossbreeding" remarkably easy: a one-time read-through and access to the tables is all that should be necessary to get gamers into the monster-making business ... or art ... or defiant tampering with the Laws of Nature, depending upon your point of view.The book is set up like the other Encycloaediae Arcane, with an introduction to the subject and the book, and closing words from the designer (author Jonathan Richards). The beginning of the book's "meat" discusses the general hows and whys of crossbreeding, and is lacking, in this reviewer's opinion, in a sufficient exploration of the MOTIVES for crossbreeding. One way this might have been rectified is by including more grey-lighted narratives of "actual" crossbreeders (such as Waldimer, who has a full page across from the Introduction, but of whom we hear no more, or Sasha, on page 33, whose "successful" experiment on herself doesn't quite satisfy her). Other gamers do not like such narratives, I know, and dismiss them as "fluff," but the subject of magical crossbreeding has been dealt with rarely in gaming -- I can think of only one instance in "regular" D & D, a quasi-example in "Ravenloft" (which would be the ne plus ultra of settings for crossbreeding experiments, although this book is geared towards "normal" fantasy worlds), and of course there are the various insanities perpetrated by cultists in "Call of Cthulhu." It would have been very nice to have more insight into the mindset of crossbreeding wizards rather than just dismissing crossbreeding as a stage in a typical wizardly career (which it most certainly isn't). I think Jonathan Richards shows himself as a good enough narrative writer that a bit more of the "grey matter" would have been helpful.Richards does introduce one very powerful rule mechanic which deserves adoption in most games: the reason why hybrid monsters can't be "simply" created with a polymorph spell is that there MUST exist a template creature for a creature being transformed by a polymorph spell. Fuzzy bunnies exist, therefore a creature may be polymorphed into a fuzzy bunny. Owlbears exist, so creatures may be polymorphed into owlbears. Richards suggests, however, that before the first owlbear was created by crossbreeding, it would have been impossible to polymorph anything into an owlbear. Very Platonic. Very useful. And a good reason for mages to want to crossbreed creatures: to make things into which to polymorph other creatures. Richards also suggests that polymorphed creatures are reproductively of their original species. As I understood it, this means that a human polymorphed into a fuzzy bunny may "go at it" as often as a fuzzy bunny, but its offspring would have to be human, and it could not sire a human-bunny crossbreed; this suggests that a male and female human polymorphed into fuzzy bunnies would spawn a human child, one whose birth would undoubtedly kill the mother, making fuzzy bunnydom a particularly hideous torture for an evil mage to inflict.Richards provides an elegantly simple chart for what the monster type of a crossbreed would be, and I found nothing to argue about in it. An "aberration" crossed with a "vermin" yields an "aberration;" a "humanoid" crossed with an "outsider" yields another "outsider" (damn those evil cultists!). Note that in order to properly understand this chart one must be familiar with monster "types" as outlined in the Dungeons & Dragons Core Rulebook III, the "Monster Manual" (3rd edition or 3.5, the latter being "official" now)."Crossbreeding" next gives a selection of suggested magical crossbreeding rituals (followed by attendant new magical items for said rituals). Parents should note that Richards does not give details for any of these rituals which might lead an impressionable youngster to actually undertake a magical hybridization of Fluffy and Kitty. Richards states in his Designer's Notes that this was to allow gamers to create spells appropriate to their own campaigns, but it also makes the book acceptable to younger gamers than it would have been had he introduced more specifics.Tables of possible results from various crossbreeding experiments are given (and reproduced inside the covers). These deal with most eventualities of crossbreeding experiments, detailing the possible results of crossing what with what to obtain this or that result. Note that a familiarity with the core rules of the d20 system are required to apply these in a game, although someone playing D &D under second edition rules (or playing an entirely different game) could probably "homebrew" adaptations of the charts for the local gaming campaign."Crossbreeding" also has a large selection of "known" hybrids (which means creatures into which others may be "officially" polymorphed if these rules are adopted for a game). Among the noteworthy critters are the "Gulor," a cross between an orc and a wolverine, the "Ooze Hound," a hybrid of riding dog and grey ooze, the "Slithertoad," part snake and part toad, the "Skyshark," a flying cross of dire bat and shark, and the "Haemovorid," a hybrid of pixie and stirge ("I'm not making this up, you know!"). Although some gamers simply can't get enough of new monsters, this is one section which I personally found over-long, and I would have gladly sacrificed the page-and-one-half given to the Mud Elemental (are there not enough on the Para-Elemental Plane of Mud or Ooze or whtever it's called?!) for more narrative material. ("Fluff!" comes the cry from the peanut gallery, but I stand by my opinion.)Another reviewer has already zapped "Crossbreeding" already for a serious editorial gaffe which I must echo: on page 30 an incorrect illustration is used for the "Spidertoad," the new hybrid familiar which is used as an example for a crossbreeding experiment -- our first held-by-the-hand walkthrough of the process. The illustration shows the result of an arachnid-fey crossing, apparently, not a spider-toad hybrid. Woe betide the foolish GM who uses the illustration as an example of what a "spidertoad" looks like!I really enjoyed "Crossbreeding." Its rules mechanics were clearcut and easily applicable, its layout was almost uniformly good, and the charts on the inside covers were very useful. I give "Crossbreeding" four stars and recommend it for Gamemasters and (with GM approval) for PCs, too.</blockquote>

Verification