Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="CanadienneBacon" data-source="post: 6707839" data-attributes="member: 11146">Thanks, guys.&nbsp; Here's what I'm considering, in current (admittedly irrational) order of preference:X1 Isle of Dread (1e lvl 3-7):&nbsp; It's pulpy.&nbsp; I'd like to do something pulpy.&nbsp; But dinosaurs might be a little too weird for a party with dwarves.&nbsp; Still, the level is probably about right.S4 Lost Caverns of Tsojcanth (1e lvl 6-10):&nbsp; A classic.&nbsp; Then again, most of everything on this list is a classic, so that's probably not enough of a compelling reason.&nbsp; Also, level 6-10 1e might be a heck of a lot harder for a party of 5e at character levels 5-7.&nbsp; The worry is that this one would be too hard.I6 Ravenloft (1e lvl 5-7):&nbsp; Ravenloft's a classic.&nbsp; I've been in the mood for horror.&nbsp; Still, not convinced this would work for the current party composition.&nbsp; One of the players has an EN World screen name of Strahd_Von_Zarovich.&nbsp; Awkward!G1-3 Against the Giants (1e lvl 8-12):&nbsp; This one would probably fit best, thematically.&nbsp; But lvl 8 might well prove to be lethal for my party.&nbsp; Would require finetuning.N1 Against the Cult of the Reptile God (1e lvl 1-3):&nbsp; No real clue why I put this one on the list, other than it's a classic.&nbsp; Too low level?B2 Keep on the Borderlands (Basic D&amp;D lvl 1-3):&nbsp; I mean, hey, it's a throwback all the way to Basic D&amp;D.&nbsp; One negative is that it was re-worked and published for 4e, so players may have played it recently.&nbsp; That'd lessen its allure.&nbsp; Also, too low level?C3 Lost Island of Castanamir (1e lvl 1-4):&nbsp; By this point in my list, I'm really just grasping at straws.&nbsp; Too low level?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="CanadienneBacon, post: 6707839, member: 11146"] Thanks, guys. Here's what I'm considering, in current (admittedly irrational) order of preference: [B]X1 Isle of Dread[/B] (1e lvl 3-7): It's pulpy. I'd like to do something pulpy. But dinosaurs might be a little too weird for a party with dwarves. Still, the level is probably about right. [B]S4 Lost Caverns of Tsojcanth[/B] (1e lvl 6-10): A classic. Then again, most of everything on this list is a classic, so that's probably not enough of a compelling reason. Also, level 6-10 1e might be a heck of a lot harder for a party of 5e at character levels 5-7. The worry is that this one would be too hard. [B]I6 Ravenloft[/B] (1e lvl 5-7): Ravenloft's a classic. I've been in the mood for horror. Still, not convinced this would work for the current party composition. One of the players has an EN World screen name of Strahd_Von_Zarovich. Awkward! [B]G1-3 Against the Giants[/B] (1e lvl 8-12): This one would probably fit best, thematically. But lvl 8 might well prove to be lethal for my party. Would require finetuning. [B]N1 Against the Cult of the Reptile God[/B] (1e lvl 1-3): No real clue why I put this one on the list, other than it's a classic. Too low level? [B]B2 Keep on the Borderlands[/B] (Basic D&D lvl 1-3): I mean, hey, it's a throwback all the way to Basic D&D. One negative is that it was re-worked and published for 4e, so players may have played it recently. That'd lessen its allure. Also, too low level? [B]C3 Lost Island of Castanamir[/B] (1e lvl 1-4): By this point in my list, I'm really just grasping at straws. Too low level? [/QUOTE]

Verification