Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="gyor" data-source="post: 7810398" data-attributes="member: 6670153">This the kind of logic that has made most of the 5e books a sloppy mess and setting lore tangled and confusing at times. MTOF, VGTM,&nbsp; and XGTE are all messes that really don't know what they want to be, so they are all a mix of high quality with utterly embarassing crap and ****ups up lore. It even makes them hard to review because they are, all basically two or more books haphazardly mashed together. They often can't agree on which setting the book is supposed to be for. &nbsp;XGTE is both the most useful for players of these books and also the biggest rage inducing rip off of a book (17 pages of names, %&amp;%&amp;%!).&nbsp;The SCAG doesn't suffer from this and neither does WGE,&nbsp; but the SCAG needs it's own version of Rising From The Last War,&nbsp; because it's too skinny,&nbsp; and it's subclasses should have been properly playtested first. &nbsp;The PHB is still the most useful book of course and suffers from none of these flaws.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="gyor, post: 7810398, member: 6670153"] This the kind of logic that has made most of the 5e books a sloppy mess and setting lore tangled and confusing at times. MTOF, VGTM, and XGTE are all messes that really don't know what they want to be, so they are all a mix of high quality with utterly embarassing crap and ****ups up lore. It even makes them hard to review because they are, all basically two or more books haphazardly mashed together. They often can't agree on which setting the book is supposed to be for. XGTE is both the most useful for players of these books and also the biggest rage inducing rip off of a book (17 pages of names, [I]%[/I]&%&%!). The SCAG doesn't suffer from this and neither does WGE, but the SCAG needs it's own version of Rising From The Last War, because it's too skinny, and it's subclasses should have been properly playtested first. The PHB is still the most useful book of course and suffers from none of these flaws. [/QUOTE]

Verification