Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="hawkeyefan" data-source="post: 8268596" data-attributes="member: 6785785">I quoted it in the same post. Here it is again:But you claim this isn’t you saying that D&amp;D, with its “weak” or “light” exploration and social rules, does exploration and social gameplay as well as games that have stronger mechanics in these areas. I don’t see what other interpretation could be made from this, but go ahead and clarify if you were trying to make a different point. I have no axe to grind. I’m here to compare D&amp;D to other games, per the stated purpose of the thread. I think that other games can very often do things better than 5E D&amp;D. I think that D&amp;D is a bit flexible, but I think you’re overstating how flexible, and the ease with which it can be changed to deliver different experiences effectively. Sorry if my comments aren’t to your liking, but the topic caught my eye. If you want to discuss how awesome D&amp;D is and how it can do everything, then next time name the thread “How Awesome is 5E AmIrite?!?!” or something and I’ll happily ignore it. But if you frame it as comparing D&amp;D to other games, then you should probably expect people to talk about the benefits of other games.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="hawkeyefan, post: 8268596, member: 6785785"] I quoted it in the same post. Here it is again: But you claim this isn’t you saying that D&D, with its “weak” or “light” exploration and social rules, does exploration and social gameplay as well as games that have stronger mechanics in these areas. I don’t see what other interpretation could be made from this, but go ahead and clarify if you were trying to make a different point. I have no axe to grind. I’m here to compare D&D to other games, per the stated purpose of the thread. I think that other games can very often do things better than 5E D&D. I think that D&D is a bit flexible, but I think you’re overstating how flexible, and the ease with which it can be changed to deliver different experiences effectively. Sorry if my comments aren’t to your liking, but the topic caught my eye. If you want to discuss how awesome D&D is and how it can do everything, then next time name the thread “How Awesome is 5E AmIrite?!?!” or something and I’ll happily ignore it. But if you frame it as comparing D&D to other games, then you should probably expect people to talk about the benefits of other games. [/QUOTE]

Verification