Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="mamba" data-source="post: 9464402" data-attributes="member: 7034611">if you expect your criticism to result in a change to the game, then yes, but then so would be nearly all criticism of basically anythingI don’t think I agree beyond your three itemsof course not, that is why I considered eliminating rulings futile and certainly not a reasonable goalI did not say they tried, I said attempting to do so in an effort to remove DM empowerment is futilewhat attacks a monster has and what their results are is described in the stat block, at a minimum DW does not describe the resultsThat a DM can change the monster to have additional abilities or can come up with out of combat ‘actions’ is besides the pointwhich still means it answers more questions than a DW one. I never claimed it answers all questions, only that it is more prescriptive than the DW one and the latter is more open to ‘DM empowerment’ (which was described as having vague / incomplete rules to allow for rulings by the DM) as a consequence</blockquote>

[QUOTE="mamba, post: 9464402, member: 7034611"] if you expect your criticism to result in a change to the game, then yes, but then so would be nearly all criticism of basically anything I don’t think I agree beyond your three items of course not, that is why I considered eliminating rulings futile and certainly not a reasonable goal I did not say they tried, I said attempting to do so in an effort to remove DM empowerment is futile what attacks a monster has and what their results are is described in the stat block, at a minimum DW does not describe the results That a DM can change the monster to have additional abilities or can come up with out of combat ‘actions’ is besides the point which still means it answers more questions than a DW one. I never claimed it answers all questions, only that it is more prescriptive than the DW one and the latter is more open to ‘DM empowerment’ (which was described as having vague / incomplete rules to allow for rulings by the DM) as a consequence [/QUOTE]

Verification