Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Chaosmancer" data-source="post: 8538202" data-attributes="member: 6801228">Sure, but it generally doesn't meaningfully matter to the adventure being played. It can't, because if it did then it would be part of a series.Let's take what is, to my knowledge, the most connected two adventures currently in 5e. Rise of Tiamat and Storm King's Thunder. Storm King's Thunder has the Ordning broken because the giant's didn't act to stop Tiamat's rise. But, the adventure is fairly clear that the Small Folk don't really know this, and frankly the entire adventure can work without this being true. You don't need Rise of Tiamat to have happened, or the people and towns attacked and destroyed to have been destroyed to play Storm King's Thunder. And this is my point. By the time you are playing Wild Beyond the Witchlight is the Mad Mage Halaster dead? He is fought and killed in Dungeon of the Mad Mage, correct? That came out before Witchlight so he is clearly dead... except, what if your table has never played Mad Mage? Is he still dead? If I want to play Mad Mage after Wild Beyond the Witchlight, do I have to explain that Halaster was killed, but has been revived? No. I don't. Because in the reality I'm playing in, those events didn't happen in that order. Enforcing that via a "shared universe" is impractical at best./////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////But if you are playing in the Forgotten Realms and I'm playing in the Forgotten Realms... aren't there two Forgotten Realms? This is why I proposed the model I did. Because every table makes its own reality, its own mirror. We all do this, constantly. In my version of setting X this isn't true and instead it is this, and that is just as "real" and "true" as your version of setting X where it is true. And this has been the model WoTC has been working under for decades, but people keep trying to claim some sort of far more bespoke version of realities where there is only one Forgotten Realms and only one Dark Sun, despite all the problems that inevitably causes./////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////Both of these kind of prove my larger point though. Who was the Mortal who slew Demogorgon and took the title Prince of Demons? None of us can say. Any answer we give is equally true, but wouldn't that person and his companions be the biggest deal, people as famous as Driz'zt or Elminster or Silverhand? Wouldn't the mortal heroes who rescued a Goddess be saints revered by the church of Waukeen for rescuing the Goddess? Yet... they don't exist. Look at any sourcebook talking about Waukeen since that adventure, and none of them name these heroes, if they even mention them at all. 5e Forgotten Realms was Canonically following the 4e Realms and Savage Tide... yet 5e never mentions Demogorgon being killed and a mere mortal taking his title. None of those archfey who helped fight are listed has having "once fought Demogorgon and helped slay him"So, yes, they reference, they hint, they give easter eggs sometimes... but it never actually matters. The Ten Towns are in the same state right now that they were in before Rime of the Frostmaiden. If they do more than mention "a few years ago the Goddess Auril threatened the region" in any future adventure that isn't a direct sequel to RoF then I'd be stunned. Because to do more than that, means they have to declare canonical endings. And there is no value in that.</blockquote>

Verification