Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Ruin Explorer" data-source="post: 9691933" data-attributes="member: 18">Personally Survivor feels narrow enough for me assuming the player isn't a chancer. I.e. it seems like they'd mainly use it on rolls where their life was on the line, or where they were doing to have to fight tooth and nail to get through something, which wouldn't be most rolls. Definitely worth discussing if you don't know what the player meant exactly tough - I did re: &quot;Fights Like A Tiger&quot; for example.I would be more concerned in a different game, one where you didn't have to pay a resource to invoke the trait, where it automatically applied for free, but I think that's the key limiting factor here. Even if you do have a pretty broad trait, you still only have so much Hope. Like &quot;Fights Like A Tiger&quot; could have been applied to easily 5x more rolls than it actually was, but as it cost Hope, the player didn't do that, and the much narrower &quot;Take You Down A Peg&quot; actually got applied to more rolls. I was surprised how well &quot;Memorable&quot; was applied too.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Ruin Explorer, post: 9691933, member: 18"] Personally Survivor feels narrow enough for me assuming the player isn't a chancer. I.e. it seems like they'd mainly use it on rolls where their life was on the line, or where they were doing to have to fight tooth and nail to get through something, which wouldn't be most rolls. Definitely worth discussing if you don't know what the player meant exactly tough - I did re: "Fights Like A Tiger" for example. I would be more concerned in a different game, one where you didn't have to pay a resource to invoke the trait, where it automatically applied for free, but I think that's the key limiting factor here. Even if you do have a pretty broad trait, you still only have so much Hope. Like "Fights Like A Tiger" could have been applied to easily 5x more rolls than it actually was, but as it cost Hope, the player didn't do that, and the much narrower "Take You Down A Peg" actually got applied to more rolls. I was surprised how well "Memorable" was applied too. [/QUOTE]

Verification