Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Umbran" data-source="post: 6163079" data-attributes="member: 177">So, what?&nbsp; The resulting fiction does not know from Hit points or saving throws.&nbsp; One day, you manage to shrug it off.&nbsp; The blows were just short of lethal.&nbsp; The next day you didn't, and they weren't.&nbsp; It isn't that you &quot;forgot&quot; how to pull off some maneuver between one day and the next - it is that you didn't try, or couldn't quite get the setup right, so you have to try something else.&nbsp; The situation on day 2 is different, so maybe you cannot manage to accomplish the same thing.The real argument against it is how much time and fiddly-bit math would be involved each time the character swapped things around. Spellcasters are bad enough, to have the whole party doing much the same could be a burden.&nbsp;&nbsp; I don't honestly think the feats are written well for this kind of application.&nbsp; I think you'd need a full rewrite, with things beyond the basic fighter attack done as &quot;manuvers&quot;, and each manuver takes a manuver slot, just like a spell slot.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Umbran, post: 6163079, member: 177"] So, what? The resulting fiction does not know from Hit points or saving throws. One day, you manage to shrug it off. The blows were just short of lethal. The next day you didn't, and they weren't. It isn't that you "forgot" how to pull off some maneuver between one day and the next - it is that you didn't try, or couldn't quite get the setup right, so you have to try something else. The situation on day 2 is different, so maybe you cannot manage to accomplish the same thing. The real argument against it is how much time and fiddly-bit math would be involved each time the character swapped things around. Spellcasters are bad enough, to have the whole party doing much the same could be a burden. I don't honestly think the feats are written well for this kind of application. I think you'd need a full rewrite, with things beyond the basic fighter attack done as "manuvers", and each manuver takes a manuver slot, just like a spell slot. [/QUOTE]

Verification