Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Coroc" data-source="post: 7177146" data-attributes="member: 6895991">I like your defiling rules they would be sufficient for me.What I am still reasoning about is how to resolve the inferior weapons. Your latest take gives lower damage dice to weapons constructed from inferior materials and so only affects weapons which are usually crafted from metal. That gives weapons such as simple clubs a big knack or do you rule that a bone great club is inferior to a wooden one? How rare is wood on Athas?Giving these inferior weapons a normal die anyway  and metal nonmagic  as well as magic ones a die up would hurt no one.How would your rules e.g. classify an obsidian longsword +1 would it do 1d6+1 / 1d8+1 versatile?Imho that's a thing to reconsider.With 5e I believe it is much easyer to just refluff things instead of rulings.</blockquote>