Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Lord Judas" data-source="post: 2226635" data-attributes="member: 16154">Well, the other thread was closed, but I am still interested in the mechanics of the actual puzzle in question.I noticed that the question of whether the two sets of symbols that would give a clue to the solution being in the wrong place was never answered. Was there an error in presentation?Btw, going by the last DM response, I am now inclined to believe there was no actual solution (likely due to the question above), or it was so alien it would have taken a Gygax-ian leap of logic to solve it. Like &quot;fill in the symbols&quot; meant filling up all the walls *except the puzzle area or some other non-sense. The DM's refusal to give the answer, and his claim the he might reuse it, re-inforces this belife. I wager that there is an no answer due to a slightly erred presentation and the &quot;2nd time around&quot; the puzzle will be correctly presented.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Lord Judas, post: 2226635, member: 16154"] Well, the other thread was closed, but I am still interested in the mechanics of the actual puzzle in question. I noticed that the question of whether the two sets of symbols that would give a clue to the solution being in the wrong place was never answered. Was there an error in presentation? Btw, going by the last DM response, I am now inclined to believe there was no actual solution (likely due to the question above), or it was so alien it would have taken a Gygax-ian leap of logic to solve it. Like "fill in the symbols" meant filling up all the walls *except the puzzle area or some other non-sense. The DM's refusal to give the answer, and his claim the he might reuse it, re-inforces this belife. I wager that there is an no answer due to a slightly erred presentation and the "2nd time around" the puzzle will be correctly presented. [/QUOTE]

Verification