Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="bestone" data-source="post: 3316099" data-attributes="member: 48880">Your just said what i said multiple times, SUBJECTIVE, i never once said they shouldnt get experience for defeating one, not once, like i said, entirely subjective, if he runs away and a)destroys the town, then perhaps not b) leaves and goes away, then perhaps yes. again, all subjectiveRight.....i think thats a rather obvious statement? and irrelivent to what i was sayingyou can say that all you want, thats your opinion, your entitled to it. Who says his minions wouldnt attack anyways? Would you really award the pc's experience for something worth a lot of it, just because it was hanging around when battle started? I wouldnt even consider it part of the encounter if it escaped right away, and again, thats based on opinion, arguing points of opinion is pointless. You then go on to say is the town still safe? did he press the button, and like i said, its subjective, i dont get the point your trying to make? your basically going into more detail and agreeing that its all subjective? which is what im sayingAgain, subjective, If he runs without ever taking part, its up to the dm to make a call. I'll agree with you tho, if you knock him out, kill him, bind him, you deserve experience, fleeing and subjecting is subjective, it depends entirely on the situation. Your entitled to whatever opinions you want, and can make whatever calls you want, you can consider him part of the encounter all you want for just being there with his minions, thats your call, but theres no hard rule telling me i have too</blockquote>

[QUOTE="bestone, post: 3316099, member: 48880"] Your just said what i said multiple times, SUBJECTIVE, i never once said they shouldnt get experience for defeating one, not once, like i said, entirely subjective, if he runs away and a)destroys the town, then perhaps not b) leaves and goes away, then perhaps yes. again, all subjective Right.....i think thats a rather obvious statement? and irrelivent to what i was saying you can say that all you want, thats your opinion, your entitled to it. Who says his minions wouldnt attack anyways? Would you really award the pc's experience for something worth a lot of it, just because it was hanging around when battle started? I wouldnt even consider it part of the encounter if it escaped right away, and again, thats based on opinion, arguing points of opinion is pointless. You then go on to say is the town still safe? did he press the button, and like i said, its subjective, i dont get the point your trying to make? your basically going into more detail and agreeing that its all subjective? which is what im saying Again, subjective, If he runs without ever taking part, its up to the dm to make a call. I'll agree with you tho, if you knock him out, kill him, bind him, you deserve experience, fleeing and subjecting is subjective, it depends entirely on the situation. Your entitled to whatever opinions you want, and can make whatever calls you want, you can consider him part of the encounter all you want for just being there with his minions, thats your call, but theres no hard rule telling me i have too [/QUOTE]

Verification