Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="The Little Raven" data-source="post: 3915647" data-attributes="member: 10095">Well, if you weren't using the Ethereal Plane, Astral Plane, or Shadow Plane, then you had to be making some kind of modification for particular spells to work, or where particular creatures come from. If you didn't use the concept of the Positive Energy Plane, then how does healing happen and where does it summon that positive energy from (since healing was a Conjuration spell)?How?3e took Greyhawk and made it 3e's mythology. They didn't make up something new, they took something old.So, you start your post claiming that you don't know Greyhawk, and end it by saying you know what it isn't?Almost every single generic D&amp;D book assumed Greyhawk as the default setting, which is why we end up with Bigby, Leomund, Mordenkainen, Knight Protectors of the Great Kingdom, Pelor, Kord, and all of those wonderful Greyhawk setting elements in the core rules and beyond.Well, since you already admitted to not knowing Greyhawk, I'll take this with a grain of salt.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="The Little Raven, post: 3915647, member: 10095"] Well, if you weren't using the Ethereal Plane, Astral Plane, or Shadow Plane, then you had to be making some kind of modification for particular spells to work, or where particular creatures come from. If you didn't use the concept of the Positive Energy Plane, then how does healing happen and where does it summon that positive energy from (since healing was a Conjuration spell)? How? 3e took Greyhawk and made it 3e's mythology. They didn't make up something new, they took something old. So, you start your post claiming that you don't know Greyhawk, and end it by saying you know what it isn't? Almost every single generic D&D book assumed Greyhawk as the default setting, which is why we end up with Bigby, Leomund, Mordenkainen, Knight Protectors of the Great Kingdom, Pelor, Kord, and all of those wonderful [b]Greyhawk setting elements[/b] in the core rules and beyond. Well, since you already admitted to not knowing Greyhawk, I'll take this with a grain of salt. [/QUOTE]

Verification