Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Tom Cashel" data-source="post: 156673" data-attributes="member: 321">Hong, do me favor and drop that smart-aleck attitude.&nbsp; You don't know Thing One about my campaign.Telling all the other players to wait outside, and then going into the gruff bar and ordering warm milk, seems designed to set up a long and possibly humorous scene for one player.&nbsp; That's grandstanding, and it's not &quot;the basic act of going into a bar,&quot; or there wouldn't be a whole thread devoted to it.Read my story hour if you want to know the tone of my campaign.&nbsp; It is indeed ineteresting...for all the members of the group, not just the one who insists on going off on his own all the time.I'd really like the DM in question to weigh in on this.&nbsp; His reasons for what he did would explain a lot.Of course!&nbsp; Don't you? (grumble...bitch...gripe...)Criminy...if the DM had said to the player, &quot;They beat you to within an inch of your life (1 hp), take all your magic items, and toss your bruised body into the gutter,&quot; then I can see how you might have a point with what you're saying.&nbsp; They just &quot;threw him out.&quot;&nbsp; The DM skipped the rules for six guys grappling one halfling, and said, &quot;they throw you out.&quot;This is all getting kind of circular without hearing the DM's opinion.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Tom Cashel, post: 156673, member: 321"] Hong, do me favor and drop that smart-aleck attitude. You don't know Thing One about my campaign. Telling all the other players to wait outside, and then going into the gruff bar and ordering warm milk, seems designed to set up a long and possibly humorous scene [i]for one player[/i]. That's grandstanding, and it's not "the basic act of going into a bar," or there wouldn't be a whole thread devoted to it. Read my story hour if you want to know the tone of my campaign. It is indeed ineteresting...for [i]all[/i] the members of the group, not just the one who insists on going off on his own all the time. I'd really like the DM in question to weigh in on this. His reasons for what he did would explain a lot. Of course! Don't you? ([i]grumble...bitch...gripe...[/i]) Criminy...if the DM had said to the player, "They beat you to within an inch of your life (1 hp), take all your magic items, and toss your bruised body into the gutter," then I can see how you might have a point with what you're saying. They just "threw him out." The DM skipped the rules for six guys grappling one halfling, and said, "they throw you out." This is all getting kind of circular without hearing the DM's opinion. [/QUOTE]

Verification