Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Arashi Ravenblade" data-source="post: 3269653" data-attributes="member: 15630">There was an edition skirmish at my place last saturday between the majority of the group and our resident OD&amp;D player who plays 3e to have something to do. I wont go into extreme details but lets just say he came in a poor mood about 3e or my Dming style (of which only he and like one other person have ever disliked, both because it wasnt 1e enough for them), not certain of which, but i came ready to defend myself and the game. His reasons where pretty lame. Something about not getting a sense of where we where cause we moved around alot, and not having maps (#1 I dont provide my players with maps unless they can find a cartopgrapher who has mapped the area and #2 im not describing in fine detail the style of every single city or area. sometimes a forest is a forest.) or enough Dungeons Crawls. Personally, and this can be done with any edition of the game in my opinion (but he seems to think its an edition thing) but i like huge epic storylines that take you from small hamlets to large godly planes, to even the pits of hell.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Arashi Ravenblade, post: 3269653, member: 15630"] There was an edition skirmish at my place last saturday between the majority of the group and our resident OD&D player who plays 3e to have something to do. I wont go into extreme details but lets just say he came in a poor mood about 3e or my Dming style (of which only he and like one other person have ever disliked, both because it wasnt 1e enough for them), not certain of which, but i came ready to defend myself and the game. His reasons where pretty lame. Something about not getting a sense of where we where cause we moved around alot, and not having maps (#1 I dont provide my players with maps unless they can find a cartopgrapher who has mapped the area and #2 im not describing in fine detail the style of every single city or area. sometimes a forest is a forest.) or enough Dungeons Crawls. Personally, and this can be done with any edition of the game in my opinion (but he seems to think its an edition thing) but i like huge epic storylines that take you from small hamlets to large godly planes, to even the pits of hell. [/QUOTE]

Verification