Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="BryonD" data-source="post: 5443869" data-attributes="member: 957">4E allows you to be affected, but avoid petrification.I dislike that it is a fort save because that clearly suggests that the effect has been shrugged off.  On that particular I'll readily agree with criticism.But if a save represents that last gasp hope that maybe you controlled yourself, or just got really lucky, or whatever, and managed to still not see her, then that save is completely consistent with the source.If you see her, you are stone.If you don't, nothing happens. There are no shades of grey.  4E is all about shades of grey, so it is out.3E RAW is about shrugging it off and that is also wrong.But the root SoD mechanic is completely fitting.</blockquote>