Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="seebs" data-source="post: 6755910" data-attributes="member: 61529">If you want to seriously argue that they aren't the same entity, you are going to break a huge number of rules. For instance, why does Amrien's player get to pick actions for Snuggles? If Snuggles eats a goodberry, does Amrien starve to death from not-eating later, because only Snuggles was affected by the magic?That's not gonna work. You have to assume some amount of intended continuity.It's sort of rude to imply that it is absolutely impossible for anyone to understand your point but not agree with it. Unless you have some kind of formal certification that you are the single human being whose ability to understand rules is the uncontested best in the world, you might want to consider the possibility that other people who view the rules differently are not necessarily stupider or less-informed than you; it's possible that there is simply an ambiguity that they're perceiving and you aren't.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="seebs, post: 6755910, member: 61529"] If you want to seriously argue that they aren't the same entity, you are going to break a [b]huge[/b] number of rules. For instance, why does Amrien's player get to pick actions for Snuggles? If Snuggles eats a goodberry, does Amrien starve to death from not-eating later, because only Snuggles was affected by the magic? That's not gonna work. You have to assume some amount of intended continuity. It's sort of rude to imply that it is absolutely impossible for anyone to understand your point but not agree with it. Unless you have some kind of formal certification that you are the single human being whose ability to understand rules is the uncontested best in the world, you might want to consider the possibility that other people who view the rules differently are not necessarily stupider or less-informed than you; it's possible that there is simply an ambiguity that they're perceiving and you aren't. [/QUOTE]

Verification