Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Maxperson" data-source="post: 6763177" data-attributes="member: 23751">You don't get to have it both ways.&nbsp; Either the full damage has to be done before the effect can happen, or it doesn't.&nbsp; If it doesn't, then your earlier claim that disintegrate must deal full damage before its effect can happen is wrong and it can have an effect with only partial damage.No you don't.&nbsp; You can only reduce a target to 0, so no more damage is applied once the target hits rock bottom.&nbsp; You are fabricating rules again.There is no damage reduction rule that says that once you hit 0 all further damage is dealt, but reduced.&nbsp; 50 - 80 = -30.&nbsp; That's the only result that can happen from full damage being dealt.&nbsp; Since you can't go to -30 and there is no damage reduction rule, damage must stop once you hit 0.I showed you the rule.&nbsp; Once you hit 0 any damage that hasn't been applied is now &quot;remaining damage&quot;.&nbsp; It has to be unused or it couldn't be &quot;remaining.&quot;&nbsp; Remaining damage is only used for massive death.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Maxperson, post: 6763177, member: 23751"] You don't get to have it both ways. Either the full damage has to be done before the effect can happen, or it doesn't. If it doesn't, then your earlier claim that disintegrate must deal full damage before its effect can happen is wrong and it can have an effect with only partial damage. No you don't. You can only reduce a target to 0, so no more damage is applied once the target hits rock bottom. You are fabricating rules again. There is no damage reduction rule that says that once you hit 0 all further damage is dealt, but reduced. 50 - 80 = -30. That's the only result that can happen from full damage being dealt. Since you can't go to -30 and there is no damage reduction rule, damage must stop once you hit 0. I showed you the rule. Once you hit 0 any damage that hasn't been applied is now "remaining damage". It has to be unused or it couldn't be "remaining." Remaining damage is only used for massive death. [/QUOTE]

Verification