Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="EzekielRaiden" data-source="post: 9498769" data-attributes="member: 6790260">The claim made (not in the post I actually quoted, I just didn't feel like digging up the true original) specifically said that if the players got a mix of lots of items that weren't at all useful (that is, explicitly including cleric-specific weapons that nobody in the party would be using) in one adventure, and then in a completely separate adventure they got few to none, they'd openly complain that the DM was ruining their immersion. And that, specifically because not enough cleric-specific (and thus mostly useless) items had been included. Different phrases used, but it's the same meaning.I 110% agree that good bookkeeping about magic items is important. (Especially since I was lax about it at one point as DM, and it was a headache to fix, though my players had done nothing wrong.) But there's a very big difference between "we kept a record of treasure" and "we are straight-up comparing an itemized list between this campaign and the last campaign, there aren't enough cleric items, this is so unrealistic, how could you ruin the game like that?!"</blockquote>