Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Varis" data-source="post: 4693013" data-attributes="member: 82427">No, I just communicated the observable facts.&nbsp;No, but they did see evidence of the water erosion on the stone path they were using. The stone was smooth.&nbsp;Yes, to clarify, it's used once at midnight, 7 days a week.&nbsp;I told them this, except for the 'Probably closed' part. There was no observable way for them to know this, except for the fact that water wasn't actually gush out of the pipe.&nbsp;If they had arrived at the pipe at midnight on any other night, they would of observed this. &nbsp;Agreed&nbsp;By the same token, saying this could be construed by the players to me that theres 'nasty' in the pipe waiting to be killed. The players had the pipes described to them, they knew the pipes had no bars on them.&nbsp;&nbsp;The clues to that were the slime on the pipe inner walls (as opposed to the pipe being bone dry), the waste nature of the water itself (which they were informed about), and the fact that it is servicing a citadel which is still used by the dwarves to this day.&nbsp;Correct.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Varis, post: 4693013, member: 82427"] No, I just communicated the observable facts. No, but they did see evidence of the water erosion on the stone path they were using. The stone was smooth. Yes, to clarify, it's used once at midnight, 7 days a week. I told them this, except for the 'Probably closed' part. There was no observable way for them to know this, except for the fact that water wasn't actually gush out of the pipe. If they had arrived at the pipe at midnight on any other night, they would of observed this. Agreed By the same token, saying this could be construed by the players to me that theres 'nasty' in the pipe waiting to be killed. The players had the pipes described to them, they knew the pipes had no bars on them. The clues to that were the slime on the pipe inner walls (as opposed to the pipe being bone dry), the waste nature of the water itself (which they were informed about), and the fact that it is servicing a citadel which is still used by the dwarves to this day. Correct. [/QUOTE]

Verification