Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Lyxen" data-source="post: 8400141" data-attributes="member: 7032025">We have definitely not read the same book and watched the same film. When does this happen ?And where do we know this from ?I actually did, you know, but all the examples that you show prove exactly the contrary of what you are trying to prove.And again, how does this prove that men can use magic ? She was a real demi-goddess.Yes, with his sword. Where is the magic here ?Again, power is not the issue here, it's the type of power. So far, all the examples that we both have given show that certain individuals, and only those, because of their lineage or because of prophecy, can use certain types of power. I don't see ANY of the humans/hobbits in LotR showing the slightest possibility of getting the power exhibited by NPCs/Adversaries, that's all.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Lyxen, post: 8400141, member: 7032025"] We have definitely not read the same book and watched the same film. When does this happen ? And where do we know this from ? I actually did, you know, but all the examples that you show prove exactly the contrary of what you are trying to prove. And again, how does this prove that men can use magic ? She was a real demi-goddess. Yes, with his sword. Where is the magic here ? Again, power is not the issue here, it's the type of power. So far, all the examples that we both have given show that certain individuals, and only those, because of their lineage or because of prophecy, can use certain types of power. I don't see ANY of the humans/hobbits in LotR showing the slightest possibility of getting the power exhibited by NPCs/Adversaries, that's all. [/QUOTE]

Verification