Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Micah Sweet" data-source="post: 9273961" data-attributes="member: 6747251">Here's my thought.  Any version of D&D published by TSR or WotC is D&D because...they own the IP and have the right to do so, despite some of those being very different games.  Any product that is broadly compatible with any of those versions (like Pathfinder to 3.5, Level Up to 5e, or many OSR games to B/X or 1e) are also D&D as far as I'm concerned, even if those D&D-adjacent games are not compatible with each other (because those games are based on different D&D games).  Basically, I want them to share real mechanical links to any official D&D game, past or present, for me to call them D&D.  PF2E has IMO drifted too far off that signal for me to consider it D&D any longer. Obviously all of this my opinion.</blockquote>