You should allow multiple choices in the pole...
A few hand painted, more prepainted (mostly plastic, but one high quality prepainted metal was used to good effect a few sessions back), yes dice (the cleric's player forgot his mini at the last session, so he was the 12 sider) and counters...
including Fiery Dragon counters. I got there Creature Collection Digital recently, and it is good: with a color printer and some cardstock type paper, you have an endless supply of quality counters