Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Rocket your D&D 5E and Level Up: Advanced 5E games into space! Alpha Star Magazine Is Launching... Right Now!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Kinneus" data-source="post: 6499341" data-attributes="member: 48215">No, I saw them. I just think it's a tad ridiculous that I have to edit a monster to get a basic elven scout, or a dwarven warrior or something like that.For example: I was personally disappointed that atropals weren't in the MM, because they're a personal favorite monster of mine. But you'll notice I didn't include that in my list of gripes earlier, because I don't think it's a legitimate complaint. Sure atropals are cool to me personally, but they also are kind of a niche monster, and the MM was pretty packed as it was, so I can understand why they wouldn't be included.It would be an unusual campaign, though, where the party didn't encounter elves, dwarves, skeletons or zombies even once. So the fact that they don't get any (or, in the case of basic undead, more) attention seems unusual to me. Not quite a mistake, not quite an oversight, but a design/editing decision I don't personally agree with at all. So a gripe, I guess. I hear a lot of people say, "Oh, there's no difference between an orc skeleton or a human skeleton." Agreed! There is, however, a very large difference between a human skeleton and an owlbear skeleton. Or an orc zombie and chimera zombie. This is why a template would've been useful, and it's baffling to me that's lacking in a book that managed to find space for flumphs, xorn, and like six dang pages for modrons. Did the designers really think, "Oh, we don't need to include stats for a dwarven warrior. When do PCs ever run into those? But let's make sure to include the merrow, everybody knows mutated evil mermaids are a mandatory part of any campaign."So not only did it fail to cover the basics (in my eyes; yes I can modify the NPCs but it strikes me as odd that I have to modify anything to make a bog-standard elf), what is there is overly-focused on "evil humanoids what hit you with clubs." Seriously. Like a dozen monsters fall into that category. Goblins, hobgoblins, bugbears, gnolls, orcs, ogres, trolls, ettins, hill giants, grimlocks, troglodytes, kobolds... and I'm probably missing a few. We have pages and pages of those. And even where there were opportunities to differentiate some creatures mechanically (like salamanders), nope. We got more of the same; evil humanoid with oh yeah sure fire resistance.Again, I love the 5e MM. I'm just saying it wasn't perfect.</blockquote>

Verification