Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="GMforPowergamers" data-source="post: 8960651" data-attributes="member: 67338">no grey is were most of us live... black and white is for movies books and games.no... then it isn't compatible it is just the same.So complete warrior isn't a reprint of the PHB it isn't the exact same, but it is compatible with the 3.5 PHB.XXXX guide to&nbsp; XXXX is teh basic new splat book title theme... so they are NOT reprints or 'the exact same' they expand on the PHB from 2014 (what I would call OG 5e)some books that are compatible add expansions and some add optional rules and some add both.the PHB from 2014 (and the DMG I would add) is the base of the system and the books that come out after are compatible.the 2024 book isn't adding to the 2014 book it is replacing it... makeing a new baseline. that new baseline isn't just &quot;not exactly the same&quot; but it's replacing wholesale classes races feats, feat progression, weapon info, action types, spells, conditions...again... no. However if you say that a new PHB with new rules that are very diffrent buyt along the same lines IS COMPATIBLE, then yes every (atleast) wotc version of the game is... they all are roll d20 you want high, they all have increasing AC, they all have the same set up for what a class is... it's only the specifics that change.now you are being inulting for no reason...is there a reason we don't just address the argument not the poster anymore? is that not the rules around here?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="GMforPowergamers, post: 8960651, member: 67338"] no grey is were most of us live... black and white is for movies books and games. no... then it isn't compatible it is just the same. So complete warrior isn't a reprint of the PHB it isn't the exact same, but it is compatible with the 3.5 PHB. XXXX guide to XXXX is teh basic new splat book title theme... so they are NOT reprints or 'the exact same' they expand on the PHB from 2014 (what I would call OG 5e) some books that are compatible add expansions and some add optional rules and some add both. the PHB from 2014 (and the DMG I would add) is the base of the system and the books that come out after are compatible. the 2024 book isn't adding to the 2014 book it is replacing it... makeing a new baseline. that new baseline isn't just "not exactly the same" but it's replacing wholesale classes races feats, feat progression, weapon info, action types, spells, conditions... again... no. However if you say that a new PHB with new rules that are very diffrent buyt along the same lines IS COMPATIBLE, then yes every (atleast) wotc version of the game is... they all are roll d20 you want high, they all have increasing AC, they all have the same set up for what a class is... it's only the specifics that change. now you are being inulting for no reason... is there a reason we don't just address the argument not the poster anymore? is that not the rules around here? [/QUOTE]

Verification